Ask most property management companies what’s keeping them up at night, and you’ll hear the same answers: high turnover, growing delinquencies, and increased pressure to differentiate. But underneath those operational challenges lies a deeper one: resident disengagement. It’s not just about rent being paid on time. It’s about whether residents feel connected enough to stay.

That’s where rewards programs are becoming a key differentiator. These programs are about small, but meaningful recognition that make residents feel valued, ultimately building more trust and more loyalty.

‍

What’s Actually Driving Resident Loyalty?

Amenities and good marketing might bring someone in the door. But they don’t keep them there. What does? A mix of small, positive experiences that build over time. Things like quick responses to issues or maintenance requests, a sense of community, and being recognized for repeating certain behaviors.

That’s the real power of resident rewards: creating an everyday feedback loop for the residents. According to Domuso’s 2025 Resident Survey, 36% of residents said they’d be more likely to renew their lease if offered the ability to earn rewards. Earning a few points for paying on time and a few more for completing a feedback survey act as a nudge to keep people engaged and feeling good about where they live.

Industries from retail to travel have used similar systems for decades, and with good reason—they work. In multifamily, we’re finally starting to treat retention with the same precision.

‍

What Good Programs Look Like

The goal isn’t to hand out perks. It’s to shape behavior that benefits the resident and the property.

That means:

• Targeting specific actions like digital payments, lease renewals, and on-time rent payments
• Offering rewards people actually want
• Making it easy to understand and use

It also means that a good loyalty program needs to be consistent. One-off concessions or sporadic giveaways and contests won’t move the needle.

Programs that work feel like part of the resident experience. That’s why so many PMCs partner with companies like Domuso to help manage and roll out resident rewards.

‍

The Business Case Is Growing

So, what is the business case for making rewards part of your resident strategy?

First, reward programs are far more sustainable than concessions and won’t lower net operating income. While concessions might grab attention, they don’t make residents feel connected and are often forgotten almost immediately. Rewards programs offer repeated value without resetting baseline rent expectations.

They also foster loyalty. They create stickiness by building trust and recognition over time which leads to higher resident satisfaction, more renewals, and stronger retention without increasing marketing spend. Retaining current residents is much cheaper than turning a unit, and loyal residents tend to be easier to manage, more likely to refer friends, and less price-sensitive when rents go up.

A good rewards program can reduce friction across the board and give you another lever to pull when budgets are tight and expectations are high.

‍

Why Rewards Programs Work

Residents want to feel like they matter. Not just when they’re signing a lease or posting a review, but on a regular, ongoing basis.

By integrating rewards programs, PMCs can build stronger communities and improve retention by changing the relationship between residents and property teams.

Stop by and see us at Apartmentalize to learn more about the benefits of rewards.

‍